Welcome To Booked And Bewitched
Enter: guilty pleasure horror romance books.
Let’s be real for a second—some books aren’t meant to be fine literature. Some books are pure, unhinged chaos, dripping in scandal, and filled with the kind of drama that makes your Kindle overheat. Think slasher villains getting a redemption arc, monstrous lovers that should be terrifying but are somehow hot, and plots so ridiculous you can’t help but devour them like popcorn at a midnight showing of Rocky Horror Picture Show.
These books don’t care about your delicate sensibilities. They’re here to ruin your life in the best possible way. So buckle up, grab a questionable glass of wine, and let’s dive into the most unhinged, deliciously dark, and wildly entertaining horror romance reads that you know you want to read.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you. Please read https://bookedandbewitched.com/disclaimer/” full disclosure for more information
What Exactly is a Guilty Pleasure Horror Romance?
Ah, guilty pleasure—a term we throw around when we’re too embarrassed to admit we love something. But in reality? There’s no guilt, only pure, unfiltered joy.
Horror romance books have an edge. They take the intensity of horror—blood, fear, heart-racing moments—and lace it with unapologetic attraction, monster smooching, and enough tension to snap your spine in half. The result? Books that make you question your life choices while gleefully adding more to your TBR.
If you’ve ever:
💀 Rooted for the slasher villain instead of the final girl
😈Wanted a monster to “ruin your life” in a good way
👻 Thought, “Why is this horrifying thing…kind of hot?”
…then congrats! You’re in the right place. Now, onto the books! Oh and if you need more fun horror choices go check out-
🎃🔪💋17 Horror Romance Books You’ll Fall For
🩶🎃🔪The Best Horror Perfumes for Women
👻🩶🎃Dark, Twisted, and Utterly Addictive Love Stories
The Most Deliciously Chaotic Guilty Pleasure Horror Romances
1. Scream for Us by Molly Doyle
Ever fantasized about being caught between three masked slasher villains on Halloween night? No? Well, too bad because this book is about to ruin your life in the best way possible. It’s fast-paced, dangerously hot, and so over-the-top that you’ll be questioning every decision you make while reading. Enter: guilty pleasure horror romance books.
Good girl Quinn didn’t expect her night to turn to mayhem once she stepped into a legendary Halloween party. After needing a quick rescue from a stranger, she finds herself locked in a captivating game of infatuation with three masked men. Her one demand? The game ends at dawn.
As desire collides with danger, how much can Quinn take before the sun comes up? Will her condition of only one night be enough? Or will her masked men leave their mark?
2. No Place To Hide by Harper Ashley
Look, sometimes we don’t need a deep plot—we just need a monstrous creature with bad intentions and a lot of…energy. If you ever wanted to know what Beauty and the Beast would be like if the Beast stayed beastly, here’s your answer.
All I wanted was one night.
A simple night of fun with my friends at the carnival.
I didn’t know I’d spend it learning things I never knew about myself.
Every twist and turn of our game brings us deeper into our desires.
But what’s a little pain if it’s mixed with unimaginable pleasure?
3. Such Sharp Teeth by Rachel Harrison
A werewolf love story with bite—literally. It’s sexy, it’s snarky, and it somehow blends horror, humor, and romance in a way that feels both chaotic and suspiciously relatable. If you’ve ever had an existential crisis while dating, this book will hit way too close to home.
Rory Morris isn’t thrilled to be moving back to her hometown, even if it is temporary. There are bad memories there. But her twin sister, Scarlett, is pregnant, estranged from the baby’s father, and needs support, so Rory returns to the place she thought she’d put in her rearview. After a night out at a bar where she runs into Ian, an old almost-flame, she hits a large animal with her car. And when she gets out to investigate, she’s attacked.
Rory survives, miraculously, but life begins to look and feel different. She’s unnaturally strong, with an aversion to silver—and suddenly the moon has her in its thrall. She’s changing into someone else—something else, maybe even a monster. But does that mean she’s putting those close to her in danger? Or is embracing the wildness inside of her the key to acceptance?
4. Slash or Pass by Tylor Paige
This book asks the important question: What if the slasher villain actually got the girl? If you’ve ever side-eyed the masked killer and thought, “You know, he could get it,” this one’s for you.
Hidden deep in the forest, we were stolen away, condemned to a life of darkness and desperation, locked away in the Sinister Minister’s basement.
For six years, Kansas, Constantine, and I clung to each other inside the Church. Just three small children fighting to survive. Until one day, I was given a cruel ultimatum, marry one boy, bury the other.
Kansas and I escaped that day, and spent the next ten years fighting to erase our pasts. Living healthy, happy, albeit chaste, lives. I made a promise to Constantine, and despite everything, I intend to keep it.
5. by Jodie King
A witch. A vampire. A whole lot of sexual tension. This is one of those guilty pleasure horror romance reads that will have you biting your nails and screaming at the characters to just get together already.
6. The Basilisk’s Kiss by Lindsay Straube
You ever looked at a basilisk and thought, “You know what? He needs a love interest.” No? Well, this book thought it for you. Unhinged, wild, and completely ridiculous, The Basilisk’s Kiss is the monster romance equivalent of pure serotonin.
Twenty-year-old Temperance Verus has never been kissed. But that’s what the basilisk is for.
Along with thirteen other contestants, Tem must train with a basilisk to learn the power of seduction and win the prince’s hand in marriage. When Tem is matched with Caspen, the Serpent King, she realizes she might actually stand a chance.
But with tensions rising between the basilisks and the humans, Tem is suddenly torn in two directions. As her bond with Caspen deepens, so does her connection with the prince. When she uncovers a terrible secret about the royal family, Tem finds herself caught between two worlds, neither of which she can survive without.
7. Beneath The Dirt by N.J. Weeks
Ghost romance? Check. Haunted house? Check. Main character who absolutely should not be falling in love with the thing haunting her? Also check. Spooky, swoony, and definitely questionable, definitely guilty pleasure horror romance books.
It’s not the house that’s haunted, it’s your heart… A woman with inner demons that rival the ones she writes about.
A man whose conscience died the moment she betrayed him. Will time heal all wounds or will the score only be settled once one of them is where all problems lay to rest?
Beneath the dirt.
8.
You want morally gray monsters? You got ‘em. This book is a fever dream of dark desire, gothic horror, and the kind of romance that makes you reevaluate everything.
My life was normal. Just my mom and I, living in a small town on the East Coast. The eve of my twenty first birthday, it all changed.
A father I have never known returned and took me away from all I knew. Trapped and tortured. Destined for something I knew nothing about. Little did I know, my entire life, I’d been haunted by the devil himself. He was always watching and waiting. As leader of an infamous cult in our area, this is no longer a haunting. He is here. And I’m terrified.
9.
A paranormal romance featuring a Halloween theme? Groundbreaking. But hey, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it! Enter: guilty pleasure horror romance books.
One year ago, on a rainy night, I made a horrible mistake. A mistake that would haunt my every waking moment. I accidentally killed Nate, the star quarterback. Or so I thought.
Now he’s back from the dead. Nothing will quench his thirst for revenge. Not until my broken pieces lie scattered by his feet and he’s inhaled my last breath. The only way out is in a body bag.
10.
We’ve all had bad exes. But have you ever had an actual demon for an ex? guilty pleasure horror romance books explores that very specific nightmare with humor, heat, and plenty of paranormal drama.
They’re dead.
I watched them die. That’s the only reason we’re here in the no-name town,
living in this creepy old house, whose shadows promise more than just darkness.
The only thing worse than the house are the woods behind it.
Where the whispers in the wind lead you to a deafening silence.
Something lurks here, nests here, 𝘵𝘩𝘳𝘪𝘷𝘦𝘴 here. It feeds on us.
Our chaos, our anger, our 𝘥𝘦𝘴𝘪𝘳𝘦.
11.
Another monster romance because, let’s be real, we love them. If you like your love interests with sharp teeth and no morals, this one’s calling your name.
A teacher. A student. A scarecrow.
One dangerously lusty halloween night in a small Ohio town that will never be forgotten.
Embrace the Chaos
Let’s be honest—none of us are reading these books for their deep themes or literary merit. We’re here for the vibes. The sinful, unhinged, “this is ridiculous but I love it” vibes.
So stop pretending you have self-control and just dive in. Life is too short to deny yourself monster boyfriends, sexy slashers, and haunted romances that make absolutely no sense.
Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have a date with my Kindle and some very bad decisions.
This website is a participant in, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to multiple .com sites. Visit our legal page for full details.
