Welcome To Booked And Bewitched
Because Who Needs a Budget When You Have Pure, Unfiltered Terror?
Horror games are supposed to be terrifying, right? Then why do so many big-budget AAA horror titles feel like they’re more interested in cutscenes and overused jump scares than actually making you afraid to turn off the lights? Enter indie horror games—where small teams (or sometimes one deranged genius) craft some of the most nightmare-inducing experiences with a fraction of the budget and a whole lot of guts.
The best indie horror games prove that you don’t need Hollywood-level CGI or a marketing team throwing millions at influencers to scare the hell out of people. All you need is a disturbing atmosphere, a sprinkle of existential dread, and just the right amount of “I hate this, but I can’t stop playing.”
Below, we’ve rounded up indie horror games that will ruin your sleep schedule, your sanity, and maybe even your relationships. Enjoy!
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through my links, at no extra cost to you. Please read https://bookedandbewitched.com/disclaimer/” full disclosure for more information
What Makes Indie Horror Games Scarier Than AAA Titles?
If you’ve ever played an indie horror game, you already know they hit different. Here’s why:
•Creative Freedom – No publishers breathing down their necks means indie devs can experiment with wild, unhinged ideas. Want a horror game where you date eldritch gods? Done. How about one where you’re trapped in an infinite IKEA? Yep, that exists.
•Less Hand-Holding – AAA horror games love their overly scripted set pieces, but indie horror thrives on unpredictability. The scariest moments are the ones you never saw coming.
•Genuine Passion – These games are made by people who live and breathe horror. They don’t care about mass appeal—they just want to traumatize you in the best way possible.
•Atmosphere Over Action – Unlike some AAA horror games that forget they’re horror (looking at you, Resident Evil 6), indie horror sticks to what it does best—building an atmosphere so unnerving that just standing still makes your skin crawl.
Now, onto the games that will make you regret ever hitting “New Game.” And if you need more horror-themed entertainment choices. Go check out-
🧟♀️🎮25 Nintendo Switch Horror Games🧟♀️🎮
🖤📖 23 Dark Romance Books of Twisted Love and Horror 🖤📖
🔪25 Must-Watch Teen Slasher Movies to Rattle Your Nerves 🩸🔪
Indie Horror Games
1. Lethal Company
What if your corporate job was actually trying to kill you? In Lethal Company, you and your friends play as scavengers hired by a mysterious megacorporation to explore abandoned facilities and bring back valuable scraps. The catch? Each location is haunted by absolutely horrifying monsters, and they will hunt you down if you make too much noise.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•Co-op horror makes everything worse (or better?) because watching your friend get brutally killed is hilarious until it’s your turn.
•Every monster behaves differently, meaning you’re never quite sure how you’re going to die.
•The sound design? Pure anxiety fuel.
A co-op horror about scavenging at abandoned moons to sell scrap to the Company.
2. Iron Lung
Claustrophobia? Check. Existential dread? Check. Unseen horrors lurking in the depths of an alien ocean? Oh yeah. Iron Lung traps you inside a rusted, barely functional submarine where your only goal is to take photos of strange anomalies deep below the surface. But something is down there with you.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•The entire game takes place inside one tiny, suffocating metal coffin.
•You never see the monster, but you know it’s watching you.
•The oppressive, suffocating atmosphere makes Soma feel like a beach vacation.
A short horror game where you pilot a tiny submarine through an ocean of blood on an alien moon.
3. The Mortuary Assistant
You think working at a mortuary is creepy? Now imagine being alone at night, embalming bodies, while something is watching you. The Mortuary Assistant takes the classic “haunted house” formula and dials it up to 11 by making you interact with the dead in deeply unsettling ways.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•Every playthrough is different—ghosts don’t just pop out on cue.
•The game slowly breaks you down, making you question what’s real.
•You have to embalm bodies, which is disturbing before the demons get involved.
Release Date: Aug 2, 2022
Alone with the dead… Embalm corpses, banish demons, save your soul.
4. SCP- Secret Lab
Based on the internet’s most horrifying cryptid database, SCP: Secret Laboratory is a multiplayer horror game where you’re either a scientist, security officer, or a horrifying anomaly trying to escape. Imagine Among Us, but instead of ejecting impostors, you get torn apart by reality-bending monsters.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•SCP lore is already nightmare fuel—this just makes it interactive.
•Multiplayer paranoia means you can’t trust anyone.
•Every round plays out differently, keeping the terror fresh.
Deep within a secure underground facility, a sudden containment breach allows many of the secured anomalies to escape from their chambers. Assist the Foundation in re-securing the facility, help the Insurgency in their goal to capture it, or wreak havoc as an SCP in a frantic bid to escape.
5. FAITH: The Unholy Trinity
Who knew pixel art could be this terrifying? FAITH puts you in the role of a priest attempting to perform exorcisms in the 1980s. With a deliberately old-school aesthetic and text-to-speech voices, this game proves that horror doesn’t need fancy graphics to be disturbing.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•The lo-fi art makes everything look cursed.
•The story is deeply unsettling, and the endings? Nightmarish.
•The game whispers to you when you’re not playing. Yes, really.
What you are about to do has not been approved by the Vatican. As a young priest, struggle against demons, insane cultists, and your own weakening faith in this pixel horror game inspired by the era of classic 8-bit gaming and the “Satanic Scare” of the 1980s.
6. Dredge
A fishing game? How scary could that possibly be? Well, Dredge starts as a relaxing trip on the open sea… until you realize the ocean wants you dead. Mutant sea creatures, ancient horrors, and a creeping sense of doom make this a slow-burn nightmare.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•The further you venture into the waters, the more reality breaks.
•The game never outright tells you what’s wrong, making it worse.
•You can’t fight back. You can only run—or fish for your life.
DREDGE is a single-player fishing adventure with a sinister undercurrent. Sell your catch, upgrade your boat, and dredge the depths for long-buried secrets. Explore a mysterious archipelago and discover why some things are best left forgotten.
7. Darkwood
What if Don’t Starve and Silent Hill had a baby and raised it in the middle of a haunted forest? Darkwood is a top-down survival horror game that proves you don’t need a first-person perspective to create pure, paralyzing fear. By day, you scavenge for supplies and try to reinforce your hideout. By night? You just pray the things outside don’t get in.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•It never tells you what’s happening, forcing you to piece together the horror yourself.
•The hand-drawn visuals are uniquely grotesque and unsettling.
•Every night, something watches you. And you never know when it’s coming inside.
Darkwood – a new perspective on survival horror. Scavenge and explore a rich, ever-changing free-roam world by day, then hunker down in your hideout and pray for the morning light.
8. Signalis
Set in a haunting, irradiated world, Nuclear Nightmare combines survival horror with psychological
A love letter to classic survival horror, Signalis combines eerie sci-fi settings, psychological dread, and a mind-bending narrative that slowly eats away at your sanity. You play as a technician clone searching for their lost partner on a derelict space station—except something is very wrong, and you are not alone.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•It’s got Resident Evil-style gameplay but with existential horror and cosmic dread.
•The story is deliberately fragmented, making you question what’s real.
•The soundtrack alone is enough to give you permanent anxiety.
A classic survival horror experience set in a dystopian future where humanity has uncovered a dark secret. Unravel a cosmic mystery, escape terrifying creatures, and scavenge an off-world government facility as Elster, a technician Replika searching for her lost dreams.
9. Chilla’s Art Games- The Closing Shift
If you haven’t experienced the uncomfortable, creeping horror of a Chilla’s Art game, you’re missing out. This duo of Japanese indie devs specializes in short, realistic psychological horror experiences where you play as everyday people just trying to do their jobs—until everything takes a dark turn.
Why It’s Scarier Than AAA Titles:
•The horror is rooted in reality, making it hit way harder.
•It doesn’t rely on cheap jumpscares—it builds slow-burning, deeply unsettling tension.
•The endings? Rarely happy.
The Closing Shift | 閉店事件 is a Japanese horror game about a girl on a closing shift.
Indie Horror is King
With AAA horror games increasingly leaning toward action, the best indie horror games are keeping the genre’s heart (or whatever’s left of it) beating. Whether you’re getting stalked in a mortuary, losing your mind in a cursed ocean, or just trying to survive a creepy night shift, these indie gems prove that bigger budgets don’t mean better scares.
Now, go forth and traumatize yourself. Which indie horror game messed you up the most? Drop your therapy bill in the comments below!
This website is a participant in, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to multiple .com sites. Visit our legal page for full details.
